The Same Old Thing

There is a lightning-scarred hemlock on a “corner,” where a small cove projects from the main body of Fish in a Barrel Pond. I know that casting a red humpy into the shade of that tree will often bring a trout rocketing to the surface from six feet down, up the face of a submerged ledge. If a humpy doesn’t do it, a fluttering stimulator usually will.

Down the shore a bit, that same ledge is more exposed, and it’s always worth skating an elk hair caddis over the drop-off on a warm afternoon. Adding a pupa imitation, about 18″ down, can add to the excitement, creating the potential for double hook-ups.

In the gloaming of a late spring evening, yellow drakes can come off so thick that it’s tempting to catch one fish, to show I can, and spend the next fifteen minutes just watching the orgy. Anglers lucky enough to hit the Hexagenia hatch will talk about it for years and if they never hit it again they’ll say things aren’t like they were in the old days.

I am always ready for the ant falls of August, carrying imitations as early as Opening Day, and I like going out on gloomy days because drizzly afternoons bring hatches of blue-winged olives.

blue-winged olive

Stylishly Fringed Wings

It’s possible to scare up a trout or two more often than not and, after ten years of fishing this one small lake and nowhere else, things are sometimes so dialed-in that it almost appears I know what I’m doing. Dark visions fill my head of ending up some earth-bound Mr. Castwell, doomed for all eternity to catch those same fish at the same corner “for ever and ever.”

(“Mr. Theodore Castwell” by G.E.M. Skues can be found in many collections of fishing stories and belongs on every angler’s bookshelf. ~QG)

The so-called “major” hatches of mayflies are done for the season, but there is still plenty of activity. The flies are smaller and less noticeable (some are darn near transparent) and smart anglers carry a selection of “terrestrial” patterns like beetles, spiders and ants to cover rising fish. August fishing means patience, observation and creativity, so I put my keen skills to work the other evening and was able to narrow my fly choices to six. Six flies, total; three #14 cinnamon flying ants and three #16 rusty spinners, based on the content of that morning’s spider webs.

rusty spinner

Late-season flies are just a little smaller.

Nothing doing with the ants, under the lightning-scarred hemlock or anywhere else, for that matter. As the shadows stretched to the east, I headed to one particular cove I know (just upwind from the aforementioned spider webs), tied on a rusty spinner and waited for the fish to show.

The wait was not long. Two silvery lines traced the surface as a pair of trout cruised in from the main lake. The rings of their rises rippled the reflected sky and I covered the closest fish with a cast that went where it was supposed to and landed without commotion.


Another rise, another cast to cover, another refusal. I shouldn’t say it was a refusal, though, having seen not even the slightest interest in my offering. My sixth cast shot out, and came down, with a bit more authority than intended and two silvery lines traced the surface as a pair of trout cruised back to the main lake.

I drifted over to where they had been feeding, to see what they had been feeding on, prepared to kick myself for choosing orangey-red flies over yellow or white. As it turns out, color was not the only thing a wee bit off.


Evidently, late-season flies are not always smaller.

Reeling in, I clipped off my tiny, insignificant, totally wrong fly and headed home, happy and content to have, once more, been saved from the terrible fate that befell Mr. Castwell so many years ago.

It should be noted that I was saved the next evening, too, when I headed out with nothing more than a few big #8 Hex patterns. Oh, I landed in the middle of a spinner fall, alright; dozens of rusty-colored ones, all size #16.

Never the same way twice.

Never the same way twice.






Categories: Fly Fishing, Humor, Vermont | Tags: , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Post navigation

One thought on “The Same Old Thing

  1. Bob Stanton

    That’s a great Skues story! “Hell! Exactly.” Condemned to catch trout for all eternity – horrible fate, eh?And I think it’s hell when I can’t catch ’em, much like your post.

Cast A Line

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: