A One-Way Ticket to Exile Island

When it comes to squirrels and chipmunks there is an exceptionally fine line between preposterously cute and inherently evil. The line was drawn by humans and therefore has no meaning to squirrels and chipmunks and, even if it did, they can only be cute for so long.

Last spring, a certain number of squirrels and chipmunks began exploiting the seemingly endless supply of bird seed that collected beneath the feeders. They were an efficient clean-up crew, stuffing their cheek pouches with sunflower seeds and millet, distorting their faces into gluttonous caricatures before running off to their secret larders, struggling to hold their heads up and even running sideways due to the weight. They had a good thing going but, being squirrels and chipmunks, they got greedy and messed it up.

Launching themselves from any and all nearby objects, the squirrels became furry projectiles. They would deliver glancing blows that scattered seed on the ground below, emptying the feeders at an alarming rate, but only if they could not actually catch themselves and hang on to a feeder in order to chew through plastic, aluminum and zinc-plated steel. That was like hitting the mother lode and the question of where they were stashing all that seed arose.

Clues started sprouting up in the form of sprouts. Specifically, sunflower sprouts in the ficus and millet sprouts in the African violets and, not long after the discovery of their little agricultural enterprise, it began to snow pink insulation as the squirrels adjusted the R-value of the attic to their liking by pushing it out through their newly chewed-through entrance.  

With all the cottages at Fish in a Barrel Pond full of Club members and their families, the use of guns was out of the question. Not that crawling into the attic with a shotgun was an option to begin with, but something had to be done and what was done was this:

One of the two islands on Fish in a Barrel Pond was renamed Exile Island and the entire band of greedy rodents was sentenced to live out the rest of their days there.

Using my well-developed skills of observation and a strong working knowledge of animal behavior, I determined that I would be dealing with one, maybe two squirrels, and at most a half-dozen chipmunks. I had two of those “humane” live-traps and the plan was to transfer the chipmunks to a secure rodent holding unit as they were caught, while the squirrels would be held in the traps to avoid the ugly scene I envisioned when I thought about mixing squirrels and chipmunks in a metal trash can. When each trap contained a squirrel the whole lot would be taken by boat to Exile Island.  


With peanut butter on stale bread for bait, I set the first trap on the stone wall below the house. I heard it click shut before I had the second trap set on the porch and before I could get back to see what I had caught the second trap was sprung, too. Two chipmunks in two minutes was not a bad start. Before lunch I had six chipmunks and could see no more and it was just a matter of time before two squirrels joined my collection.


I spent the rest of the afternoon watching closely, looking for signs of rodents, but no more appeared. With my estimate of their numbers confirmed, I lugged the rodent holding unit and the traps to the boat dock, where I was greeted with hoots and hollers from a group of men tying flies on the porch of the lodge while waiting for the evening hatch to roll around. I ignored their ribbing and busting of my chops and declined all bets on how long it would be until the critters swam off the island as I loaded the boat and shoved off, paddling toward Exile Island.


They might have just been happy to be out of the can but it seemed as if the chipmunks enjoyed their new home, streaking off through the undergrowth, and the squirrels climbed right up trees they had never seen before like they had lived there all their lives. It was no life for them, eating spilled bird seed and living in an attic, and I felt warm and fuzzy for having done such a good thing.


Imagine my surprise, then, when I looked out the next morning and saw not one, not two, but three squirrels launching themselves at my bird feeders. And imagine my further surprise when I trapped six more chipmunks, again, before lunch. If you can stand even more surprise, every chipmunk and squirrel trapped that second day received a free stripe of yellow paint but none of the squirrels or chipmunks trapped on the third day had been painted. Neither had the ones I trapped on the fourth day or the fifth.


In all, twenty two chipmunks and eleven red squirrels were relocated to Exile Island during the Great Rodent Roundup and, as one might expect in the woods of Vermont, I still see a few furry visitors on the ground beneath the feeders but I am not worried. Their numbers seem pretty manageable. Looks like one, maybe two squirrels and at most a half-dozen chipmunks.

Categories: Humor, Rural Life, Vermont | Tags: , , , , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Post navigation

8 thoughts on “A One-Way Ticket to Exile Island

  1. I’d be scared to death they’d take revenge before running off! Funny how such cute little critters can cause so many problems.

  2. pandemonic

    Damned squirrels.

  3. Quill Gordon


  4. Sounds like a Stephen King story. Sometimes They Come Back.

  5. I just smiled through this whole thing! Great pictures, and what a humane way to take care of this problem!

    Yay for YOU!

  6. Oh, man — we had our own stories to tell about varmints, but the best one was the skunk. Galahad attempted to chloroform it and then set it loose far, far from our house. Poor thing — it lurched around like a drunk when we let it out of the cage… But we didn’t see it return to our garage, so the goal was achieved.

  7. Rodents....

    Well, that’s one way to get rid of them. You could bring all of the neighbors’ stale food to the island to feed them, since their numbers probably outweigh food supply on the little island. Then you could end up with an island so chock full of rodents you could practicaly wade through them! Imagine….With a big enough food supply, if each chipmunk has six babies, and half are female and can thus bear offspring, and with the disproportionate numbers of rodents to predators meaning that a few snatched by hawks would make little difference, how much would you have in ten years?! Let’s see, 22 chipmunks total. So say 11 females. They each have 3 female babies….66 babies, and that’s just in one year!

  8. TJM

    Pops called squirrels, ‘rats with tails’.

    Now it wasn’t so much that Pops didn’t like squirrels; what it was was, Pops liked birds. Specifically, Pops enjoyed watching the birds feed at his bird feeders.

    And the squirrels, who also feed at his bird feeders, were an obstacle to his enjoyment.

    After a time, Pops got so tired of the squirrels eating his bird seed that he bought a humane trap and set out to banish the squirrels from our neighborhood.

    He would catch the squirrels in the humane trap and then release them at a park on the other side of the city.

    After a summer of this with no seeming decrease in the squirrel population along Birch Street, Pops decided to get a bit more scientific. He wanted to figure out if the squirrels were coming back to eat his bird seed from way across the city.

    To mark the squirrels, he would catch them in the humane trap and, before he released them on the other side of the city, he would spray paint their tails. That way, if the squirrels came back, he would see their painted tails and know that they had made it back to our yard.

    So, Pops being Pops, his little squirrel painting hobby grew until the garage was full of old spray paint cans and he had relocated squirrels from our neighborhood to most parts of Worcester.

    The next summer, our whole family was at a cook out in Leister, up near the airport. The yard we were in was next to the woods that surrounded the airport. And I was pretty sure the airport was one of the places that Pops freed his painted squirrels.

    So I found a man at the party we didn’t know. I explained Pops’s hobby and asked the man if he would start a conversation with Pops. I instructed the man to say that one day he was in his backyard and he swore he saw a squirrel with an orange tail run by.

    Well, the man was a good sport, and off he went in search of Pops. Not having a poker face, I decided to watch from the other side of the patio.

    The man found Pops, they started talking and I thought “oh, I got him this time.”

    So, after a few more minutes, Pops laughed and started looking around the yard.

    He caught me watching them and immediately walked over to me.

    As Pops approached me, I said to him “Well, that didn’t work, did it?”

    Pops said, “No, it didn’t. I knew there was no way he had seen a squirrel with an orange tail.”

    “All the squirrels I released at the airport, I painted their tails purple.”

Cast A Line

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: